They beckon you from across Duval Street. You first get a whif of the fresh-baked scents coming from the shop. Then you look over and see them displayed in the window. They’re the largest chocolate chip cookies you’ve ever laid eyes on and, lucky for you, they’re made right here in Key West. You figure, I’m on vacation in a tropical paradise, so I might as well indulge. As they say, “YOLO.” Once you take that first bite into one of Mattheessen’s signature chocolate chip cookies, you’ll instantly be impressed. “How does something that big pack so much flavor?,” you’ll wonder. To be honest, I don’t know how they do it. But every single one of them is made from scratch and tastes as good as the next. Each cookie tastes like it’s straight out of the oven! Moist, gooey, and worth every penny of the $5 you’ll pay. Mattheessen’s will even ship if you get that craving back home.